LiveWire Network Peer Answers Peer Support Teen Forums Tech Forums College Forums 635 users online 186482 members 2243 active today Advertise Here Sign In
TeenCollegeTechPhotos | Quizzes | LiveSecret | Video | Dictionary | News | FAQ
You have 1 new message.
Emergency Help
Until you sign up you can't do much. Yes, it's free.

Sign Up Now
Membername:
Password:
Already have an account?
Invite Friends
Active Members
Groups
Contests
Moderators
9 online / 19 MPM
Fresh Topics
  LiveWire / Teen Forums / The Intellectual Forum / Viewing Topic

Vivisection is scientific fraud
Replies: 24Last Post April 29 5:32am by The Samsoniteman
Welcome to LiveWire!
We're Stronger Together.
Join the Community
Pages: 1 2 Email Print Favorite
Web Resources: Drug Myths Dispelled, Drug & Alcohol Information
USA Drug Abuse Hotline: 1-800-662-4357
( Loud Dog )


Soothsayer
Reply
Black, if you can't tell if I'm joking, assume that I am. I got the quote line from a Disrupt song. I just wanted to know how people go about justifying animal experimentation.

Norock, your defense of abuse of nature seems to wander straight through moral relativism and set up camp in sociopathy. Hell, if less orders are fair game to be abused, why don't we just cut out the middle man and test drugs on poor people? They're inferior to us, right, and in nature animals have no time for the weak, and it would save money on welfare, and the results would be even more applicable! Right?

-------
The Polito form is dead, insect.


4:35 am on April 28, 2008 | Joined Jan. 2006 | 479 Days Active
Join to learn more about Loud Dog England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | 6099 Posts | 10847 Points
norock


Connoisseur
Reply
I did not say other animals were inferior to us, and I did not say that we should abuse the power we have.
I do not think that we should throw a few chemicals together and say "lets see what THIS does to some animals"

Obviously, there should be careful research done and enough chemical and biological understanding of the drug being tested so that as little harm --if any-- can come to a very small group.

Humans are a specieistic animal, we look out for our own, I would NEVER condone human testing unless the drug had been tested on animals so that it was believed to be safe, and only then with the consent of the human party.

There are some things that must be done for the advancement and up-keep of our species. If you have a better Idea of how to make sure drugs will not be harmful to the body, I'd be glad to hear it.

-------
            ...life is good...
...mai ho oni i ka wai lana malie...


6:31 am on April 28, 2008 | Joined Dec. 2006 | 343 Days Active
Join to learn more about norock New York, United States | Straight Male | 4170 Posts | 7580 Points
Blackadder


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
Quote: from Loud Dog at 12:35 pm on April 28, 2008

why don't we just cut out the middle man and test drugs on poor people? They're inferior to us, right, and in nature animals have no time for the weak, and it would save money on welfare, and the results would be even more applicable! Right?

We do.  - What type of person signs up for clinical drug trials?

Volunteers are paid up to £150 a day to take part in clinical trials.

Healthy volunteers are used to test the safety of the drug in "phase one" of the trial before further tests with people who have the condition to determine whether the drugs work.

£150 a day certainly insn't going to intice a hot-shot laywer into risking his health....

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/4807042.stm



-------
The truth is what money can be made from a lie.


7:24 am on April 28, 2008 | Joined Oct. 2004 | 931 Days Active
Join to learn more about Blackadder England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | 4334 Posts | 13761 Points
( Loud Dog )


Soothsayer
Reply
Hey, I never mentioned PAYING them for it...

So do humans not have any responsibility to safeguard the "lower orders"? Or do we get special privilidges to say "it's okay, this is how things go down in nature" while at the same time abusing the natural order of things for our own gain?

-------
The Polito form is dead, insect.


7:51 am on April 28, 2008 | Joined Jan. 2006 | 479 Days Active
Join to learn more about Loud Dog England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | 6099 Posts | 10847 Points
norock


Connoisseur
Reply
Put it however you want. Nature is, and has always been the survival of the fittest.

I believe that we have a certain responsibility to use only what is necessary and follow the conditions I mentioned above; but the fact remains that we are still animals, and the survival of OUR species is paramount to us.

-------
            ...life is good...
...mai ho oni i ka wai lana malie...


10:33 am on April 28, 2008 | Joined Dec. 2006 | 343 Days Active
Join to learn more about norock New York, United States | Straight Male | 4170 Posts | 7580 Points
TheOtherHorseman


Where shall wisdom be found?

Patron
Support Leader
Reply
Quote: from Loud Dog at 6:22 am on April 25, 2008

"It's unscientific, immoral and finacially unsound. It's also dangerous because the results do not apply easily to humans."

Dispute.


There is literally no way it can be inherently unscientific. Either you do it scientifically or not. It is also probably much more financially sound than just making a bunch of drugs and jumping into human testing and hoping for the best, or by trying to expensively simulate in vivo conditions in vitro.

One would imagine it is also less dangerous than just throwing drugs at humans and hoping for the best.

The only leg you have to stand on is being against it based on morality, and that varies from person to person, so you'll be wrestling with shadows on that one.

-------
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!"


5:07 pm on April 28, 2008 | Joined June 2003 | 1445 Days Active
Join to learn more about TheOtherHorseman Massachusetts, United States | Straight Male | 13199 Posts | 35000 Points
( Loud Dog )


Soothsayer
Reply
Well, I was thinking about taking a moral absolutist angle, but norock pissed all over that one before I even got started on it.

-------
The Polito form is dead, insect.

5:22 pm on April 28, 2008 | Joined Jan. 2006 | 479 Days Active
Join to learn more about Loud Dog England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | 6099 Posts | 10847 Points
TheOtherHorseman


Where shall wisdom be found?

Patron
Support Leader
Reply
Where does the absolutism come from, though? Is it from a higher power? If so, then that can be handwaved away as a religion that the opponent doesn't believe in. Is it drawn forth from some apparent fundamental truth of reality? Easy peasy taking that down, just adopt a fundamentally opposing philosophy and then shout each other hoarse.

It would be a tiring conversation.

-------
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!"


5:29 pm on April 28, 2008 | Joined June 2003 | 1445 Days Active
Join to learn more about TheOtherHorseman Massachusetts, United States | Straight Male | 13199 Posts | 35000 Points
Blackadder


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
ahh, ethics, lets debate it!


"animal testing is just plain wrong becau...."

"a-a-ah, your forgeting somthing"

"what"

"error theory"

"fuck, I was kinda hoping you had forgotten about that."

"nope, sorry"

"ah well, you up for ice-cream and scrabble?, I think I might stand a chance of winning that"

-------
The truth is what money can be made from a lie.


6:22 pm on April 28, 2008 | Joined Oct. 2004 | 931 Days Active
Join to learn more about Blackadder England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | 4334 Posts | 13761 Points
The Samsoniteman


Dairy Product Addict
Reply
Horseman, I don't reject animal testing on principal but there's an unfortunate gap between how it's carried out now and how it should be carried out if science has anything to do with it.

Researchers keep lab pets, reject or ignore new computer technology that can replace or reduce the need for animal tissue and researchers and their funders often try and downplay concerns over the fact that rats simply aren't people.

-------
Massive, epic adventure, multi-coloured, multi-layered.
Sort of two/three dimensional Wizard of Oz for the future.


5:32 am on April 29, 2008 | Joined June 2004 | 1070 Days Active
Join to learn more about The Samsoniteman England, United Kingdom | Straight Male | 12472 Posts | 23003 Points
Pages: 1 2 Email Print Favorite

Quick Reply

Prereq. Intellectual Test
You are signed in as our guest.

Looking for something else?
 

  LiveWire / Teen Forums / The Intellectual Forum / Viewing Topic